Today’s world is digitally connected and social media has become an integral part of our daily lives on a personal and professional basis. It’s where we find community and share our thoughts, experiences and opinions.

The rise of social media dismissal cases in the UK highlights the growing complexity of managing employee conduct online and the increasingly blurred line between professional and personal life. Understanding the implications of social media posts on employment and the associated employment law is crucial for both employers and employees. This article will explore the dos and don’ts of social media use in the context of unfair dismissal cases.

Social Media and Employment Law

Social media platforms offer a public forum where individuals can express themselves freely. However, this freedom is not without limits, especially when it comes to the workplace.

Employers are increasingly scrutinising social media activity, with some dismissing employees for posts they deem inappropriate, offensive, or damaging to the organisation’s reputation. This raises significant questions about the fairness of such dismissals, the legal protections available to employees and the risks to the organisations of taking such action.

Dismissing for Gross Misconduct

One of the primary reasons an employer may dismiss an employee over social media activity is where it is considered to be gross misconduct. This could include posting derogatory comments about the company, colleagues, or clients, or sharing confidential information. For instance, an employee who makes a negative comment about their employer on a social media account could be seen as undermining the working environment and causing potential damage to the employer’s reputation. In such cases, employers may feel justified in taking disciplinary action, up to and including dismissal.

However, it’s not always straightforward. The dismissal must be proportionate to the misconduct, and the employer must follow a fair disciplinary procedure. Failure to do so could result in the employee being unfairly dismissed, leading to a claim for unfair dismissal.

Dos and Don’ts for Employers

Do: Implement a Clear Social Media Policy

A well-defined social media policy is essential for setting expectations around online behaviour. This policy should clearly outline what constitutes unacceptable social media activity and the potential consequences of violating these guidelines.

Don’t: Overreact to Social Media Posts

While it’s important to protect your company’s reputation, it’s equally important not to overreact to every social media post. Not all negative comments warrant dismissal, and taking harsh action without considering the context can lead to claims of unfair dismissal. Instead, assess the situation carefully and consider whether the post genuinely constitutes gross misconduct.

Do: Investigate and Follow a Fair Disciplinary Procedure

If you decide to take disciplinary action against an employee for their social media activity, it’s crucial to follow a fair and transparent procedure. This includes conducting a thorough investigation, giving the employee an opportunity to explain their actions, and considering alternative sanctions before deciding to dismiss. A failure to adhere to this process can make the dismissal unfair in the eyes of an Employment Tribunal.

Don’t: Ignore the Context of the Post

Context is everything when it comes to social media posts. Before taking action, consider the tone, audience, and intent of the post. A single negative comment made in a moment of frustration may not be sufficient grounds for dismissal, especially if the employee has a previously unblemished record.

“MAD-HR were extremely professional”

“MAD-HR were extremely professional and importantly, with what was for me a very difficult HR problem, empathetic and quickly understood the situation and were very well equipped to deal with it. Very clear in explaining what could be done and how it would be executed. From the start I had complete confidence in them. MAD-HR achieved what we set out to do and kept everything on track from start to finish.” Read the full review

MAD-HR Feefo Rating

Dos and Don’ts for Employees

Do: Understand Your Employer’s Social Media Policy

Before posting on social media, it’s essential to be aware of your employer’s social media policy. This policy typically outlines what is considered acceptable and unacceptable online behaviour. Ignorance of the policy is not a defence in dismissal cases, so familiarise yourself with the rules to avoid accidentally breaching them.

Don’t: Post Derogatory Comments

Making derogatory comments about your employer, colleagues, or the company’s products and services on social media can have serious repercussions. Even if your social media accounts are private, there is always a risk that these comments could become public. Always consider the potential impact of your posts before hitting ‘send.’

Do: Keep Work and Personal Social Media Separate

Where possible, it’s a good idea to keep your professional and personal social media accounts separate. This helps to minimise the risk of work-related posts being seen by your employer and can protect your personal life from professional scrutiny. It’s also advisable to review your privacy settings regularly to control who can see your posts.

Don’t: Share Confidential Information

Sharing confidential information about your workplace on social media is a serious breach of trust and could result in dismissal for gross misconduct. This includes details about business operations, client information, or any other sensitive data. Always think twice before sharing anything related to your job online. 

The Role of the Employment Tribunal

In the UK, if an employee believes they have been unfairly dismissed due to their social media activity, they can take their case to the Employment Tribunal (ET). The ET examines whether the dismissal was fair, taking into account the employer’s social media policy, the severity of the social media post, and whether the disciplinary procedure was followed correctly.

The ET has previously ruled both in favour of employers and employees in social media dismissal cases, depending on the specifics of each case. For example, in some cases, the tribunal has upheld dismissals where employees made derogatory comments that damaged the employer’s reputation. In others, it has been found that the employer overreacted or failed to follow a fair procedure, leading to a finding of unfair dismissal.

Conclusion

The role of social media in unfair dismissal cases continues to evolve, and both employers and employees must tread carefully in this area. For employees, understanding the boundaries of acceptable social media activity and adhering to company policies is crucial to avoid disciplinary action. For employers, implementing clear guidelines and following fair procedures can help mitigate the risk of legal challenges.

In an age where social media is omnipresent, the key to avoiding disputes lies in communication, clarity, and mutual respect. By understanding the dos and don’ts of social media use, both parties can protect their interests while maintaining a positive working environment.